sig p220 vs 1911 recoil

Being an integral part of the frame, the shoulder/frame absorbs all of the shock from the impact of the slide. The P220 weighs a tad less than a lightweight Commander, 25.7 ounces unloaded. Get gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and updates on law changes daily! And, that is taking your gun a part for cleaning. With what is currently available, the P220 SAO Legion would be my first choice. Your thoughts? A lightweight service pistol is especially important in law enforcement. And, of course, there was the reliability factor. My finger simply needs to leave the trigger and rotate slightly to hit the magazine release and drop the mag. Originally designed as a military pistol, it necessitated extreme accuracy and the Girsan MC P35 does not disappoint. In fact, the P245 takes the exact same spring used on the .40/.357 P239s (and the .40/.357 Sig Pros). The original hammer/trigger system was made not of high grade bar stock or forged parts but of a cheesy powdered compressed metal (sintered) later to be replaced presently with and even worse set of parts, the disastrously inferior MIM cast parts guaranteed to go snap, crackle and pop at the most inopportune times. I had already read it and that is where my question originated since the Sig p220 is a John Browning design same as the M1911a1.The following paragraph illustrates this fact. The SIG-Sauer pistols are famous for accuracy across the board, but the P220 may be the most accurate of them all. Unless you spend the dough for an already upgraded 1911 with enhanced accessories, your run of the mill original design GI-style 1911A1 will have miserable sights, no beavertail on the grip safety, standard safety size, and probably a little short trigger that has a pull that ranges anywhere from mediocre to acceptable. Very interesting question! Taking the gun apart is very easy, and SIG makes it simple. Itll probably keep you reasonably safe in a bullseye match but I still would lay odds that a nice P220 Match Elite will probably kick the crap out of a 1911 Gold Cup at the target range too. This part will help keep your Sig Sauer Firearm in top shooting condition. "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellem" ~If you wish for peace, prepare for war~. 10mm models of the SIG P220 are great as hunting pistols, especially with an optic involved. Whats the difference in hotter 10mm? Heres the short version answer why Sig P220 trumps the 1911: Now heres the long version of this bickering: Ive always been a Sig Sauer fan and it all started when I got my first Sig Sauer P226 then wandered over to the P220 in .45 ACP years ago. The weight of the duty belt is one reason why back problems in general and lower back problems in particular seem to be an occupational hazard of the street cop. Its both tactile and audible and very nice overall. The slide lock position is towards the rear of the gun, which creates an issue for many who like a nice high thumbs-forward grip. This is the standard Nitron finish P220 Carryas good as it gets for personal defense. Unsubscribe at any time. FYI, with heavy loads the SigP220 is the more comfortable pistol to shoot, much more comfortable grips and ergomatics! Designed by John Browning, the M1911 is the best-known of his designs to use the short recoil principle in its basic design. DPMS LR-308 [Review]: The AR, Back to Basics. However, the Sig Sauer P220 benefited from another 65 years of pistol evolution and got almost everything right from the start. SIG also offers the P220 Legion in DA/SA and SAO, with the same differences between the versions as the P226 Legion. The P220 has an overall length of 7.8 inches, is 1.5 inches wide, and is 5.5 inches high. Yet, there are still debates among the hard core users. As a matter of fact there is one roll pin in the top of the frame that has its rear end hanging out in thin air and is pressed down on by a very strong spring. Sig P220-P229-SP 2022-Sig 1911-M400. I like them both very much but I also have a P226 stainless and if I were transitioning to .45 caliber I'd first go with the P220 then later chose the 1911 as your next platform. The rear sight is a windage drift adjustable sight and the front is a dovetail sight. One of those guns was a well-worn P220 European, the other, a brand new P220 American. Never as common in the police or military communities as either the P220 or P226 and pretty well replaced by the P228 and P229 today, the P225 remains a popular conventional DA/SA 9mm semiautomatic pistol. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. We dont call Canada California, just because they both start with Ca. Only our P320-F (Full-Size) guide rod and P320 X-Five (Full Size) include a 15-pound 1911 recoil spring. It always had good sights compared to most of its competition. Price $29.99. What did Sig have to do to the P220 to make it a modern fighting pistol? In free states, the eight rounds of .45 ACP severely lacks when compared to the 21 rounds I can get in a CZ P09, or even the 13 rounds I can get in a Glock 21. From the world leader in firearms . Right off the bat most gun advocates in the shooting crowd that are not die-hard 1911 users have recognize the Sig P220 taking the lead on this. Its straight, groove-free, with a very comfortable palm swell at the bottom of the grip. Firing from a single- or double-action trigger pull, this pistol is built with a 4.4 inch barrel set in a stainless steel slide topped with windage-adjustable iron sights. Length & Weight. Controls shot, right side. 2. Additionally, its easier to get an excellent high grip with a beavertail. There's nothing wrong with the original P220; it's a perfectly solid gunbut the Legion is better. Comparing two awesome .45 ACP pistol designs for SHTF. I'll take a P220 SAO over almost anything else. Total Windage Travel . Come join the discussion about Sig Sauer pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Completely non-scientific, subjective evaluation of the felt recoil and muzzle flip of the SIG P220, 1992 date, alloy frame, .45 ACP, compared to the Dan Wesson Heritage Razorback 1911, steel frame, 2011 date, .45 ACP.Results: Shooter 1 felt the SIG kicked more and the recoil felt \"faster\"; Shooter 2 felt the SIG had more recoil to the hand overall, but the 1911 had more muzzle flip. The SIG Sauer P220 is one of the few single-stack, all-steel guns still holding on in the modern age. It is about the same weight as the six-shot Smith & Wesson Model 10 or Model 64 Military & Police revolver with a 2-inch barrel. These handy units are the only part of a Sig P365 you need to go to a gun shop to receive. The fact that a single pistol with which the officer is intensively trained could be used on or off duty, in uniform or in plainclothes, is another big factor in the P220s favor when police departments look at purchasing new sidearms. If I had to pick only one 10mm it would be a P220. 5 Best .45 ACP Pistols, Sig Sauer P220: The Sig Sauer P220 Combat is a pistol with a super-light aluminum frame, which is quite different from other .45 ACPs and is very customizable. What a joke. It is a great and comfortable shooter. In stock. Photo Gallery: 14 Amazing Engraved Guns of Gun Digest 2015, Redding Releases a Number of New Precision Reloading Die Sets, SIG P365 Rose Review: The Pistols Petals And Thorns, The .380 ACP Glock 28 Is Now Available Stateside, First Look: Bond Arms Cyclops .45-70 Govt. The P220 10mm Legion has a gray finish that resembles Parkerizing. Trigger reset is more than a 1911, but less than a Glock. The 1911 has a shoulder in the frame where the slide impacts. A base model 1911 often rubs me the wrong way, but the P220 is a soft shooting, easy recoiling gun. Flawless and the weight results in 9mm-eque recoil. The triggers are almost always quite-good-to-excellent for a DA/SA gun. This allows the shooter to clear the chamber without needing to disengage the safety. SIG's P220 SAO pistol features a confluence of features that are attractive to SIG fans and 1911 shooters as well. Yeh, it was lust at first sight. The P220, which is also available with an E2 grip, is significantly more slender and maneuverable. Head to Head Comparison. It's beyond a stretch to call that an "evolution"they are different animals. Like. In 1976 the pistol was made available in .45 Auto and designed to best the 1911 in every way. I also have the sig 1911 fastback nightmare. And I might add myself, This they accomplished at the expense of durability, along with an inferior design wrote with problems, most of which never have or in some cases impossible to, correct with its ill conceived design. The SIGs double action pull was excellent, probably best of breed. It was the standard by which the competition was judged. . Ergonomics * * * * *. For those looking for an excellent mid-sized carry 1911, check out the 4.25-inch commander S&W 1911SC E-Series. March 30, 2021. Sig P220 45 Dark sig finish, 4.3" bbl . I'm keeping my P320s, but I'm selling my coffee tables!!! The P220 Legion has been redesigned to bring 10mm stopping power to the common handgun buyer. The SIG Sauer P220 is one heck of a gun. Save Compare. The Sig is older but recently been refit with all new springs and bbl, comes with multiple sig mags. The P220 felt superb, was stunningly accurate, andget THISI didnt have to do anything to it. The Glock carries thirteen rounds in its double-stack magazine, while the P220 loads eight cartridges stacked up like spoons. Its a locked-breech, short recoil-operated pistol that utilized SIGs own system. Join Date: January 15, 2006. Recoil Spring Set - P220 .45ACP, P226 . The distance the trigger had to move forward to re-set the sear was just enough to give a buffer against unintentional discharges under stress, but not so great that it appreciably slowed down the shooters rate of fire. The main objective is just quick disassembly, inspection and cleaning. Has been fired an honest 32 times and is is 99.9 perfect like new condition. The P220 is a single stack gun most famously chambered in .45 ACP. And while Id consider an FN (Fancy! With the 229 you change calibers by changing barrels (and maybe mags). Massad Ayoob. The big deal breaker will be the Sig reliability out of the box ready to rock n roll with less pampering and tampering. If you were in a situation where you knew people would be shooting back at you, and you could only choose between a Sig P220 or a 1911, both loaded with modern hollow point defense ammo, which would you grab? Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. They paid the price of a reduced in-gun cartridge capacity, only five to six rounds. Slim-ish width, great grip angle and comfortable Hogue rubber grips make it feel great in the hand. Remington? Price is certainly a factor, as is the caliber, both of which may not appeal to some. In stainless, the full-size P220 is a fairly massive handgun, and feels far bigger and chunkier that the 1911. Type 1911 into the search bar, Go ahead. Reducing the weight of the duty .45 from 39.5 ounces to 25.7 (the same round-count of the same ammunition adds the same weight to either) results in a 13.8-ounce weight saving almost a pound at a critical point. Please select the desired spring weight from the drop-down menu. The Commander, originally introduced in lightweight format in 1949, weighed 26.5 ounces unloaded and held the same number of .45, .38 Super, or 9mm rounds as the P220. Its a heavy beast best described as a boat anchor. Please note we use stock pictures that is a representation of the item and may not be the exact picture due to manufacturers design change or simple a general picture or group picture with the item . In the end, both platforms are really good choices. I'd highly recommend the stainless P220 which handles recoil smooth as butter. It will probably need a fluff n buff to make it feed defensive ammo, too. Best Selling Rifles; . {Pope Pius XI, Dec 11, 1925.}. I believe there is now a relief in the frame in the form of a notch. Save. Had a Kimber 10mm that was a jam o matic only for the first 600 rounds and still had the occasional failure. The P220 and the 1911 are comparable in size, both are fine carry pistols and I personally would never carry one of those pocket sized toys they sell. Yes and according not to me but by an article that first appeared in the American Rifleman Magazine that appeared when the Sig P220 was first introduced, the gun was designed to be made as fast and as cheap as possible. Some 1911s will handle it very well if they are built well, others maybe not so much over the long haul. Add to Cart. "Nothing is easier than the expenditure of public money. I logged in searching for info on my own P220 an European model chambered in 9mmPara (yes, they dont make them anymore) bought in 1980. The 1911 can be well, finicky. Ill go one step further: I have such complete confidence in the To hell and back reliability of the Sig Sauer P220 that if there were a pile of 50 unknown stock P220s in front of me and I had to choose just one to use as a carry gun to protect my life with, I could close my eyes, grab one, and be certain the gun would run 100%, as long as it had been properly maintained. I considered buying another 1911 but then a buddy of mine got a P226 extreme and I liked it so much I bought my own. As a modern combat handgun its lacking. SIG is known for its quality handguns, and this one is no different. I could talk about how reliable this system is but I dont need to. The P49 (Pistole 49 = SIG P210) was introduced as standard side-arm in the Swiss Army in 1949, the P75 (Pistole 75 = P220) as standard side-arm in 1975. As a hammer-fired gun, a nice beavertail means you dont have to worry about hammer or slide bite with these guns. It plowed through almost 300 rounds without so much as a hiccup or a cleaning. Now lets take a look at the design defects of this handgun. They shoot where you want and feed almost anything. Best 9mm Ammo in 2021 [Self-Defense & Target], 6.5 Creedmoor vs .243 Win Cartridge Comparison, Viridian Laser Sight AR and Pistol: Review, Marlin 1895 .45/70 Hands-On Review The Guide Gun, [Review] Ruger LCP II: The .22 Pocket Rocket, Features a low profile and higher grip for better control, Some reviews say that the frame and slides may get sloppy after lots of heavy use, but it can be remedied by adding lube, Most models only have an eight-round capacity. Grayguns fat Stainless Steel Guide Rods are available for the P320, P228, P229, P220 and P226. I think a CZ 97B might be a closer comparison in manual of arms at least to a 1911 since it has a manual safety and not a decocker like a DA/SA P220. If there is an advantage of a SAO version of the P220 over a 1911, I don't know what it is. Just letting you know.Yes, overall rating the Sig P220 wins the minds of most shooters. Sig P220, 224, 226, M400 TREAD, 516 G2 Patrol SBR, 716i TREAD, MPX K, 1911 Emperor Scorpion Fastback, 1911 TACOPS Carry, 1911 . Flip a coin. Thats cool; this article is my personal opinion. Find the right recoil spring & explore official SIG SAUER factory direct parts. The SIG Sauer P220 introduced the SIG Sauer system, which is more straightforward than the P210 and does away with the grooves in the slide and barrel as well as the locking lugs. Also worth noting: my experiences with Sigs customer service team have been nothing short of exceptional. [#11] I'd go with the P229 and the E2 grip. "Never argue with idiots. In his book The 100 Greatest Combat Pistols, defensive firearms expert Timothy J. Mullin had this to say about the P220. Because it was reverse engineered it also could not function with sharp shouldered lead bullets like the super accurate Keith 200 grain semi-was cutter. They are two distinct animals other than the commonality of caliber. The P220 is a popular gun, and its hard to point out standout features for just this model when so many different models exist. Please consider supporting me on Patreon!https://www.patreon.com/jeffshootsstuffI apologize that this video was uploa. ), HK (Nice!)) I love this gun when it comes to range time. Welcome to the forum. 8. Said system and the P220s descendants are widely used throughout the worlds militaries, including Federal Law Enforcement and elite units like the US Navy SEALs. Its certainly a weapon made for its time, and that time has long passed. He serves as an NRA certified pistol instructor and teaches concealed carry classes. If you only use 1911s for all your pistol needs, I can see this being acceptable, maybe even preferable. Engineered with a nearly straight-line feed, the P220 was reliable with almost every hollow-point bullet. See less See more Reply. Sources: Monkey Wrench, Sig Sauer, Colt, Drew Perez, Only one company builds Sig P220s (but, TJ is the man that can customize to your needs). Made to the same high standards as the parts already found in your Sig Sauer firearm. I'm Mike, one of the oldest writer of Sniper Country! While not so small overall as a snubby .38, it is very flat. Add to Cart. Pull the slide rearward until the half moon cut out of the slide is above the takedown lever. Sig Sauer P220 Legion . Multiple Handgun Mounting Kit IncludesSight Plates for - Glock (Except Mos), Cz-75, Springfield Xd, Sw Mp,Hk P2000, 1911 Standard,Sig Sauer 1911,Sig Sauer 220, 226, 227, 229-1,Sig Sauer 229 Non-1, 239, 225-1, Sp2022,Sig Sauer P320,Glock Mos,Sw Cor ; Moa Adj, black ; Total Elevation Travel - 100 MOA. It would later inspire the P228, P229, P227, and P224, and I could just keep listing pistols if youd like. It was so much fun shooting that after one shooting session I went out and bought a Sig P229, but I had wanted another P226 in .40 but the store didn't have one, but now I am glad because I like having the two different sizes. I am wondering if I should go with a quality 1911 or the sig p220 and stick with the same design as my p226? Its a massive gun with a big, wide grip a bit bigger than it needs to be. Sig Sauer Braided Recoil Spring, Suitable for: P220 chambered in 45acp-or-P226 chambered in .357sig / .40s&w This is a factory original Sig Sauer part. Once the first shot had been fired, it went to single-action, where the trigger press was a clean, easy 4 to 6pounds or so. My local dealer has a P220 Legion SAO that I will probably be bringing home. *Spoken like a good Beretta shooter bhp0!. 4. Don't get me wrong, I love 1911s. What a wonderful gun to run. Sig P220, 224, 226, M400 TREAD, 516 G2 Patrol SBR, 716i TREAD, MPX K, 1911 Emperor Scorpion Fastback, 1911 TACOPS Carry, 1911 Ultra Carry. "If I'd known I'd live this long I'd have taken better care of myself.". Go. Several Gun Writers have stated the U.S. Military rejected the Sig P226 precisely because of its weak stamped sheet metal slide which as stated was replaced with the more expensive bar stock slide. When it comes to 1911s, it's really about the individual manufacturer, and the quality of the build. That is the best way to compare it to feeling the P220. I can tell you from extensive experience with both platforms that the Sig P220, no matter its vintage, will run pretty much whatever ammo you can put through it like greased corn runs through a goose. Where to Buy Ammo Online [Complete 2021 Guide], Best Gun Cleaning Kits [AR-15, Pistol & Universal], Best Shooting Gloves [Hands-On Tested, 2021 Update], Best Universal Red Dot Sights [Hands-on Review], Best AR-10 Magazines: Ultimate Buyers Guide. There is no comparison between the two in terms of format and function. The P220 Carry is a shortened version of the full-size P220. Designed in 1975 by the SIG Arms AG division of Schweizerische Industrie Gesellschaft (now SIG Holding AG), and produced by J. P. Sauer & Sohn, in Eckernfrde; it is currently manufactured by both SIG Sauer companies: SIG Sauer GMBH, of Eckernfrde, Germany; and SIG Sauer, Inc . 1; 2; Next. All the nay sayers in the world can get me out of my German cars or guns thank you very much. 4. In stock. I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. First is Colt 1911 Government 45 ACP in blued finish, 5" bbl, two mags, blue case manual lock everything that it came with. I have to change recoil springs to go from modern weak 10mm to "real" 10mm in the Glock and the 1911. Spin the takedown lever downward, and the slide is then unlocked and removable from the frame. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. The new P320-XTen comes standard with SIG's excellent XRay 3 day/night sights and an optics cut. SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. My friend Chuck Taylor is one of the leading authorities on combat handguns and the author of a great many articles and multiple books on the topic. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. As such, it is well worth its not-inconsequential price and clearly a handgun upon which one could with confidence bet his life.. I bought the 1911 before I bought the Sigs. Its human engineering is excellent because, like its baby 9mm brothers, the P225 and P226, its controls are placed where they can be readily operated, something exceptional for a DA auto. Next time I will verify what I wrote before posting it. April 22, 2023 03:35 AM. Romans 1:16- "For I am not ashamed of the Gospel of Christ" Do we not read throughout the Scriptures that Christ is the King? Both times, the ammunition was Federal 185-grain JHP, which the manufacturer used to mark on the box as Match Hollow Point.. My range rents both 1911s and 220s. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. In this Article: Kimbers OriginsNowThe Micro 9The Micro 9 Up Close & PersonalI Like TheShooting The Micro 9How To Select Ammo For The Micro 9 A Quick PrimerCleaning/Reassembling The Micro 9And, In The End Kimber is a company that has had a rather rocky past. At one time, I had three Sig P220s of the same generation (P220s had slight generational changes to the slide and extractor setups over the years) and I conducted that very exercise. For those unfamiliar with the P220, it is the handgun the company's current stable of pistols owe their heritage to. It takes a real effort to avoid placing my thumb on the slide lock, and often once the shooting starts and pressure builds, my thumb goes tight to the grip and rests on the slide lock. The Franken-.45. The SIG Sauer P220 is an alloy-framed, semi-automatic pistol that operates on the classic Browning style tilting-barrel short recoil action. BONUS OFFER: Get your free shooting range targets to print at home! Thanks for the input so far. I have a three of Sig P220s to include a Dark Elite. When you buy a P220, you know youre getting a quality gun. SIG SAUER Legion .45 auto options include single action only with a flat trigger or SA/DA with P-SAIT trigger. All pistols have drawbacks and shortcomings. The Rifle section is dedicated to James Henry Mason, aka forum member "horse"; shooter, collector and rifle authority, who left us too soon. 5127. COLT O1911C-SS38 - 38 SUPER SERIES 70, N.M. BARREL ,CLASSIC GOVERMENT, STAINLESS STEEL FINISH, CUSTOM HAND ENGRAVED SLIDE & FRAME, CUSTOM WHITE PEARLITE GRIPS WITH COLT GOLD RAMPANT HORSE .Click for more info. Reliable, accurate, and affordable, the 336 in caliber .30-30 is a staple in the deer woods each fall. The pistol in its uniform holster rides near the edge of the hip, and on some individuals with some uniform designs, can directly contact the ileac crest of the hip. The thumbs will rest on the slide lock, which means after you fire the last round, the slide will not lock to the rear. Sig is slightly easier to field strip and reassemble. Sig Sauer P226 Full Size For Sale . Ive had both, for me, the sig is hands down the best platform foe ten mil. No spam. The history on those two pistols I cited doesn't change just because you don't like the narrative, and a supposedly 'newer, awesomer' version doesn't make the previous version less prone to failure with the full power 10mm ammo (Norma 10mm and other) the FBI and others were testing with at that time.

Thomas Costello Obituary, Stambaugh Middle School Uniforms, Articles S